Monday, May 14, 2012

Why most marriage statistics are completely skewed

Apparently Slate.com is now doing a "map of the week".  This week, it was a map of states by marriage rate.  Can't get it to format well....click on the map and drag to see other states.




It shows Nevada as the overwhelming winner, with Hawaii second.  This reminded me about my annoyance at most marriage data.

Marriage data is often quoted, but fairly poorly understood.  The top two states in the map above should tip you off as to the major problem with marriage data derived from the CDC in particular....it's based on the state that issued the marriage license, not the state where the couple resides.  Since all (heterosexual) marriages affirmed by one state are currently recognized by every other state, state of residence information is not reported to the CDC.  This means that states with destination wedding type locations (Las Vegas anyone?) skew high, and all others are presumably a bit lower than they should be.  Anecdotally, it's also conceivable that states with large meccas for young people (New York City, Boston, DC) may be artificially low because many young people return to their childhood home states to marry.  This

The other problem with marriage data is the resulting divorce data is even more skewed.  Quite a few states don't report divorce statistics at all (California, Georgia, Hawaii, Indiana, Louisiana, Minnesota) and the statistics from the remaining states are often misinterpreted.  One of the most commonly quoted statistics is that "50% of marriages end in divorce".  This isn't true.

In any given year, there are about twice as many marriages as there are divorces....but thanks to changing population, changing marriage rates, people with multiple divorces, and the pool of the already married, this does not mean that half of all marriages end in divorce.  In fact, if you change the stat to "percent of people who have been married and divorced", you wind up at only about 33%.  More explanation here.

Ultimately, when considering any marriage data, it is important to remember that there are no national databases for this stuff.  All data has to come from somewhere, and if the source is spotty, the conclusions drawn from the data will likely be wrong.  This all applies to quite a few types of data....but marriage data is used with such confidence that it's tough to remember how terrible the sources are.  A few people have let me know that I've ruined infographics for them forever, and I'm hoping to do the same with all marriage data.

You're welcome.

5 comments:

  1. Ruining infographics forever...

    What a noble goal.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. These days, around half of all marriages end in divorce.

      That’s a pretty sad statistic… especially because so many of those divorces are preventable.

      In reality, many marriages end prematurely. Why? Well, there are two reasons.

      Neither spouse knows how to prevent the passion, intimacy, and romantic connection from gradually fading away.
      They make the 3 “Marriage Murdering Mistakes” that very few people know about… and sadly, these 3 mistakes can quickly drive your marriage into disaster and divorce.
      If you’re in this situation…

      If your marriage is dead-as-a-doornail…

      If you’re heading towards divorce, or even if you’re already at that point…

      Then a new video by marriage coach Brad Browning will show you how to stop the downward spiral and breathe some life back into your relationship. (Brad’s a freakin’ genius, by the way.)

      =>Begin Repairing Your Marriage *Today* <=

      I wish I could force every couple experiencing a marriage crisis to watch this new video… because the strategies Brad reveals in it are extremely powerful and might be the difference between “unhappily divorced” and “happily ever after”.

      The best part is that you can apply the techniques described in his video on your own… without your wife even being aware that you’re making an effort to save the marriage.

      So don’t lose hope just because your partner refuses to attend marriage counselling, or won’t put in the effort to fix the problems that are slowly eating away at your marriage.

      Watch the video now by clicking here: Transform Your Marriage in Minutes<=

      There’s no catch to this, and no marketing gimmicks… just a complimentary in-depth guide to saving your marriage.

      At the very least, you should watch the first few minutes where Brad reveals the 3 ‘Marriage Murdering Mistakes’… these 3 massive myths alone are a huge reason why nearly half of all marriages end in divorce.

      Don’t give up on love yet. Take action today and begin re-building your marriage… start by clicking the link below to watch the video now.

      ==> Fix Your Marriage – Start Making HAPPY Memories<==

      The techniques in the video have already worked for hundreds of married couples…. and they’ll work for you, too. What are you waiting for?

      Here’s to a happy, healthy, and long-lasting marriage!

      Talk to you soon,

      -[[Ana]]-

      Delete
  2. Related, BTW.

    http://isteve.blogspot.com/2012/05/obamas-julia-and-affordable-family.html

    ReplyDelete
  3. not only the multiple marriages and multiple divorces of certain people but also the fact that many people who divorce remarry their spouses. great article.

    ReplyDelete