I've spent most of last week at work trying to perfect a grant proposal that pretty much everyone in our program has to sign off on. On Thursday, Friday and today there was a great deal of discussion about what metrics we could use to measure our outcomes, should we get funding.
It's actually not an easy question, as the project we're working on is a general good thing (patient education) designed to address a multitude of issues, as opposed to something more targeted.
Watching half a dozen people go back and forth about all this got me thinking about how often it is taken for granted that somewhere out there is a definition for "success" in various topics.
When I took a child development class in grad school, I remember in one of the first classes someone asked what the best parenting methods were. Our professor replied that there really couldn't be a consensus, because no one could agree on what would qualify as a success. He proceeded to use religion as an example: for parents of strong religious persuasion, a child who grew up a financially successful atheist would not necessarily be what they were going for. Conversely, secular atheist parents might be distressed at a strong religious conversion.
There are probably scores of good studies that could have been done on parenting methods if we actually had a definition of success we could all agree on. Too frequently, I think people overlook this point. The reason so many strange fads in parenting can get going is because it is really really hard to prove anyone right or wrong. Even if you try, you might just wind up with the dodo bird verdict.
If you can't agree on where you're going, you most certainly can't tell people how to get there. The studies you don't do are often as important as the studies you do.
Showing posts with label My own work. Show all posts
Showing posts with label My own work. Show all posts
Monday, June 4, 2012
Tuesday, May 8, 2012
Greetings from Maine
After a treacherous journey up Route 1 (over an hour to clear the city of Boston), I'm pleased to tell you that we're coming to you tonight from Portland, Maine.
I'm running a conference tomorrow at University of Southern Maine about bone marrow transplant patients who have to travel long distances....or as it's more flourishingly called "Improving Patient Pathways for Complex Care Across Multiple Healthcare Systems". This is not my forte, and thus I have nothing long winded tonight....but after the stress of conference planning, I'm sure I'll have to spend several weeks with nothing but numbers and spreadsheets before I calm down.
While we wait to see where that takes me, I thought I'd continue my pattern of figuring out a good Google Ngram for the trips I take. This time I decided to run all the New England states to see who got mentioned the most.
I'm happy to see Massachusetts made a strong showing. Connecticut managed to eek a win over Maine, and it looks like Vermont, New Hampshire and Rhode Island have just been hanging out for years.
I'm running a conference tomorrow at University of Southern Maine about bone marrow transplant patients who have to travel long distances....or as it's more flourishingly called "Improving Patient Pathways for Complex Care Across Multiple Healthcare Systems". This is not my forte, and thus I have nothing long winded tonight....but after the stress of conference planning, I'm sure I'll have to spend several weeks with nothing but numbers and spreadsheets before I calm down.
While we wait to see where that takes me, I thought I'd continue my pattern of figuring out a good Google Ngram for the trips I take. This time I decided to run all the New England states to see who got mentioned the most.
I'm happy to see Massachusetts made a strong showing. Connecticut managed to eek a win over Maine, and it looks like Vermont, New Hampshire and Rhode Island have just been hanging out for years.
Tuesday, April 17, 2012
Boston vs Chicago
This week, Bad Data Bad is coming to live from downtown Chicago, just a few feet away from the Magnificent Mile!
I'm at the Science of Team Science conference, and so far it's going pretty well. I got a chance to present and discuss some of my research with people last night, and it's fun having people recognize more of the psych aspect of what I've been doing. Your normal bone marrow transplant crowd really doesn't care about that part of anything, so it was nice to have people recognize the theories behind what I was doing. They're posting the abstracts online at some point, I'll link to them when I figure that out.
Anyway, on my flight out here the data geek in me realized that a Boston/Chicago comparison would be a great input for the Google Ngram Viewer. If you haven't played with this yet, it's fun. Basically it tracks how many times the words you put in were mentioned in books over the last 200 years. They uploaded a massive number of books to get the data, so the results are kind of fun. Here's Boston vs. Chicago:
For reference, Chicago wasn't founded until 1837. I tried running it starting at Boston's founding in 1630, but that made a weird spike that made the rest of the graph look silly. My guess is that's a function of fewer books from that era loaded in to the database, since the y-axis is percentage.
For more about the project behind google ngrams, here's my good friend TED to explain:
I'm at the Science of Team Science conference, and so far it's going pretty well. I got a chance to present and discuss some of my research with people last night, and it's fun having people recognize more of the psych aspect of what I've been doing. Your normal bone marrow transplant crowd really doesn't care about that part of anything, so it was nice to have people recognize the theories behind what I was doing. They're posting the abstracts online at some point, I'll link to them when I figure that out.
Anyway, on my flight out here the data geek in me realized that a Boston/Chicago comparison would be a great input for the Google Ngram Viewer. If you haven't played with this yet, it's fun. Basically it tracks how many times the words you put in were mentioned in books over the last 200 years. They uploaded a massive number of books to get the data, so the results are kind of fun. Here's Boston vs. Chicago:
For reference, Chicago wasn't founded until 1837. I tried running it starting at Boston's founding in 1630, but that made a weird spike that made the rest of the graph look silly. My guess is that's a function of fewer books from that era loaded in to the database, since the y-axis is percentage.
For more about the project behind google ngrams, here's my good friend TED to explain:
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)